Supply Chain Roundtable: ‘Turkeys Away’ and Other Assumptions to Question
Not surprisingly, this edition of Institute for Supply Management®’s (ISM®) monthly Supply Chain Roundtable discusses Thanksgiving, or at least what is probably the most notable — and definitely the funniest — Hollywood production about the holiday.
You might not know that the iconic 1978 “Turkeys Away” episode of “WKRP in Cincinnati” was based on a similar Thanksgiving promotion by an Atlanta radio station (using a truck instead of a helicopter) that went awry. For our panelists, there’s a lesson in the laughter: Don’t make a supply chain plan based on an assumption that could be wrong.
There’s a bounty of other insights, including on what procurement organizations will need from their infrastructure — and their leaders — by the end of the decade, as well as avoiding pitfalls on demand planning, one of the most challenging supply chain disciplines.
The panel:
- Neal J. Couture, FASAE, CAE, ISM President and CEO
- Michelle Rohlwing, MBA, ISM Manager, Product Development, Innovation and Learning
- Teresa O’Brien, ISM Senior Faculty Member, Product Development and Innovation
- Judith Whipple, Ph.D., Bowersox-Thull endowed professor in logistics and supply chain management at Michigan State University in East Lansing, Michigan, and member of the ISM Board of Directors.
Q: An article in the November/December issue of Inside Supply Management® discusses how organizations will evolve by 2030. What will procurement and/or supply chain operations look like in three years? What are the biggest strengths and capabilities leaders will need?
Couture: I think the bigger change will be that procurement finally stops being defined primarily by the transactions it manages and starts being defined by the intelligence and business outcomes it produces. (We’ve only been working at this for more than 40 years!) We shouldn’t simply use AI to automate today’s procurement model; we should use it as an opportunity to redesign the model. As more activity becomes digital and increasingly autonomous, traditional measures of procurement performance will also need to change. Cycle time and spend under management will still matter, but we’ll increasingly measure things like quality of decisions, ability to anticipate risk, organizational resilience and how quickly the enterprise can act on new information. The strongest leaders will be those who can design these new operating models, establish the right guardrails and measures, and turn enormous amounts of data into foresight. In three years, I think the real competitive advantage will belong to supply management organizations that can see around corners — and help the rest of the company do the same.
Rohlwing: I think procurement and supply chain will look quite different in just three years. AI and automation will handle more of the routine work, but that actually makes the human side of the job even more important. Leaders will need to understand technology and data, but they’ll also need to be strong communicators, problem solvers, and relationship builders. With continued disruption, uncertainty, and changing risks, the ability to adapt quickly and make good decisions with imperfect information will be critical. To me, the strongest supply chain leaders won’t necessarily be the ones who know everything. They’ll be the ones who stay curious, embrace change, ask the right questions and know how to bring people together to solve problems.
Whipple: I agree that AI can increasingly manage routine work, allowing procurement and supply chain professionals to focus on higher-value activities, such as supplier collaboration and supply-demand integration. Future leaders will spend more time orchestrating decisions across suppliers and customers, as well as internally with other functional areas like engineering, finance and marketing. The decisions of tomorrow will continue to become more complex due to demand shifts, demographic changes, economic and geopolitical uncertainty, and emerging technologies. While AI may facilitate better scenario planning around these changing conditions, competitive advantage will come from supply chain leaders who sense changes sooner, align stakeholders faster, and engage in cross-company, integrated decision-making that translates into stronger strategic responses.
O’Brien: The largest barrier to having a serious seat at the table for supply chain and procurement professionals is getting out from under the data gathering, crunching and last-minute demands. Emerging technology is going to allow us to get beyond performing rote activities and firefighting to focusing on future strategy at the leadership level. Three years from now, professionals will be digital-fluent, adaptable connectors within the business. I agree with Michelle; they’ll need curiosity and the courage to challenge how things have always been done. This is so exciting because I have seen so many brilliant and creative minds stagnate under the tactical minutia. Now they will be free to unleash their talents as visionaries rather than paper pushers.
Q: The Manufacturing PMI® data for October suggests that demand is there, but customers may be buying only what they absolutely need. If the floodgates suddenly opened and customers went from “minimum necessary” to “we need to catch up,” what supply chain issues or potential breakdowns should companies be aware of?
Rohlwing: If customers suddenly shift from buying only what they need to trying to catch up, the biggest risk is if supply chains can respond fast enough. Suppliers have been adjusting production, inventory and staffing to the softened demand, so a quick spike could show capacity issues overnight. We could see longer lead times, material shortages, transportation bottlenecks, and prices start moving up again. There is also the risk of companies overreacting and placing larger orders with multiple suppliers, which can make demand look a lot stronger than it really is and create the bullwhip effect. To me, this is where visibility and strong supplier relationships really count. Companies need to understand where they may run into shortages or delays now, rather than waiting for demand to take off and discovering them when everyone else is competing for the same materials and capacity.
O’Brien: Procurement needs to be proactive, working closely with suppliers and internal stakeholders to understand capacity constraints and identify alternatives before they become critical. The companies that recover fastest won't necessarily be those with the most inventory, but those with the strongest visibility, supplier partnerships, and ability to respond together.
Couture: I would watch for the speed and synchronization of the recovery. If demand accelerates quickly, the constraint may not be any one supplier — it may be the ability of the entire network to ramp at the same time, just as it was following the coronavirus pandemic. Capacity, labor, transportation and critical materials can all tighten quickly, and longer lead times can compound as companies compete for the same resources. The other risk is reacting to the surge as if it represents a permanent change in demand. If companies double-order or rebuild inventory too aggressively, they can amplify the bullwhip effect and create the next imbalance. The organizations best positioned for a rebound will be those that have visibility beyond their Tier-1 suppliers, understand where their real constraints are, and can share demand signals early enough with strategic suppliers to make coordinated decisions.
Whipple: The issue is how quickly supply chains can respond if demand suddenly rebounds. While the ISM® Manufacturing PMI® Report has generally indicated growth in production and new orders across the year, it also shows order backlogs and supplier lead times have increased. As Michelle indicated, suppliers have scaled down in the face of softened demand. Scaling back up is much more challenging, so if demand surges, we could see significant capacity constraints, including labor constraints, and even higher backorders and longer delivery times. If demand significantly exceeds supply, customers who are more proactive and collaborative may gain a competitive advantage as “customers of choice.”
Q: One of the most memorable lines in television sitcom history is, “As God is my witness, I thought turkeys could fly.” What’s a supply chain assumption that companies should be challenging right now — something treated as a certainty that actually represents a significant risk, or might turn out spectacularly wrong?
O’Brien: For years, we’ve focused on lean inventories, supplier consolidation, and driving costs down, often assuming those efficiencies make our supply chains stronger. But we’ve learned that optimizing cost alone can leave organizations vulnerable when conditions change. Leaders need to ask a different question: Are we building supply chains that are simply efficient, or ones that can actually adapt and recover? That doesn’t mean abandoning cost discipline. It means recognizing that flexibility, supplier relationships and risk management have real economic value, even when they don’t immediately show up as savings.
Whipple: To build off Teresa’s comments, one assumption to challenge is whether a cost-optimized supply chain automatically provides the highest long-term value. Resilience, flexibility and responsiveness are often viewed as expensive during stable periods, while the value of these investments may only become apparent during disruptions. Cost avoidance is a form of savings that organizations often fail to recognize, particularly when the cost of recovery — such as lost sales, service failures and stockouts — exceeds the cost of prevention. The real question is not whether resilience costs money, but whether organizations fully account for the cost of not being prepared.
Couture: One assumption I would challenge is that the next disruption will look like the last one. Companies have spent a lot of time preparing for the risks they have already experienced, but resilience is not about predicting the next crisis perfectly. It is about building the visibility, optionality and relationships to respond when the disruption comes from somewhere you did not expect. The spectacularly wrong assumption is believing that because a supply chain is working today, you understand where it will break tomorrow. Leaders should be thinking about not only what could go wrong, but also what they are assuming cannot go wrong. That is often where the real risk is hiding.
Rohlwing: An assumption companies need to challenge right now is that suppliers will always be able to get us what we need, when we need it. The October ISM® Manufacturing PMI® Report shows why: Demand and production are growing, but supplier deliveries have been slowing for 11 straight months, customer inventories are still considered too low, and prices remain elevated. In other words, business may look good on paper, but there isn’t much room for something to go wrong.